-
Top 10
June 2025
Best Amish Paste Tomato Seeds Heirloom
We made a list of the top 10 Amish Paste Tomato Seeds Heirloom based on verified reviews, popularity and other factors which we summarized for you in this list.
Best Choice
1
Tomato Garden Seeds - Amish Paste - 1 g Packet ~250 Seeds - Non-GMO, Heirloom Vegetable Gardening Seed
Mountain Valley Seed Company
9.4
VIEW DEAL
Buy on Amazon
✓
Tomato Seeds - Amish Paste - 1 g Packet ~250 Seeds - Solanum lycopersicum
✓
Non-GMO - Heirloom - Open Pollinated - High Germination Rate
✓
Seeds For: Vegetable Gardening
✓
Days to Full Maturity: 85 -- Annual -- USDA Hardiness Zone: Annual Crop, Not Intended To Overwinter
✓
Mountain Valley Seed Company Brand - Premium Quality Seeds
Learn more
on Amazon
More Info
2
Tomato Amish Paste Garden Heirloom Vegetable by Seed Kingdom (50 Seeds)
Seed Kingdom
9.0
VIEW DEAL
Buy on Amazon
✓
Lycopersicon esculentum
✓
Days Until Harvest: 74
✓
Heirloom vegetable
✓
Nice balance of sweet and acid
✓
Excellent fresh or in sauces
Learn more
on Amazon
More Info
3
Survival Garden Seeds Paste Tomato Collection – Roma & San Marzano Tomato Seeds for Planting in The Garden – Non-GMO Heirloom Seed Varieties
SURVIVAL GARDEN SEEDS
8.8
VIEW DEAL
Buy on Amazon
✓
Rich Paste Tomatoes - Amish Paste, Roma, and San Marzano tomatoes are all meaty, rich tomatoes that are prized for their flavor and texture, excellent for canning and preserving. They each have an ideal consistency for making into tomato paste.
✓
Favorite Canning Tomato Varieties - San Marzano produces 5-6 ounce tomatoes with meaty walls and small seed cavities, and is used extensively in Italian cuisine. Roma tomatoes grow to be about 3” long on vines that do well in containers.
✓
Grow Now or Later - Plant now or store for future growing seasons. Will remain viable for years if stored in a cool dry location. Each packet has instructions for saving seeds so you can perpetuate your harvest and share with others.
✓
The Info You Need to Grow - The tomato seeds are packed in a beautiful paper packet with instructions for successful growing and germination. Each package includes seed-saving instructions for beginners and experienced gardeners.
✓
Small American Family-Owned Business - We’re committed to providing fresh, high-quality san marzano tomato seeds for planting now or future seasons. Our non-hybrid, non-GMO heirloom seeds are open-pollinated and tested for germination.
Learn more
on Amazon
More Info
4
HOME GROWN Heirloom Tomato Seeds for Planting with Basil – 160 𝗡𝗢𝗡-𝗚𝗠𝗢 𝗨𝗦𝗔 Seeds Including Cherry, Roma, Beefsteak, Zebra, Yellow Plum, Amish Paste, Cherokee, Krim, Italian Basil & Thai Basil
HOME GROWN
8.6
VIEW DEAL
Buy on Amazon
✓
8 HEIRLOOM TOMATO SEEDS with 2 BASIL VARIETY & 10 PLANT MARKERS - Our pack contains the best tomatoes and basil for home gardening. Includes 1 cherry tomato seeds pack. Tomatoes: Amish Paste, Beefsteak, Black Krim, Cherokee Purple, Green Zebra, Roma, Large Cherry, & Yellow Plum Tomatoes. Basil: Italian Flat Leaf & Thai Basil
✓
NON GMO SEEDS- All of our seeds are 100% non GMO, Non hybrid, and heirloom. These can be great seeds for planting indoor and outdoor in your garden. Grow them to full size heirloom tomato plants.
✓
100% NATURALLY USA GROWN & HIGH GERMINATION RATE - All of our seeds have 95% germination rates. Grow your own food and be sure that it is pesticide free and all natural. These heirloom seeds have been tested and we 100% ensure the best quality.
✓
SUSTAINABLE HOME GARDENING - Aprox: 15 TOMATO SEEDS EACH / 20 BASIL - Have a bountiful garden this year with seeds to spare! Our seeds are meant to be used for the current season and the next! These tomato seeds for planting are great for any home gardener, chef, or prepper.
✓
PLANTING INSTRUCTIONS INCLUDED - Inside each pack we have included a growing guide. The perfect gift for the gardeners in your life! These tomato seeds for planting will be just what they want.
Learn more
on Amazon
More Info
5
Everwilde Farms - 25 Organic Amish Paste Heirloom Tomato Seeds - Gold Vault Packet
Everwilde Farms
8.5
VIEW DEAL
Buy on Amazon
✓
First Quality Organic Seeds – Current Lab Test Data Shown on Packet
✓
Exclusive Gold Vault Packaging – Provides 3X Longer Storage than Paper or Plastic with Triple Layer Mylar Gold Foil.
✓
Resealable/Reusable Zipper Bag – Perfect for Storing Excess Seeds
✓
Bulk Seed is Excellent for Immediate Planting or for Long Term Storage as an Emergency Seed Vault
✓
Detailed Planting Instructions on Back – Online Info also available via QR Code
Learn more
on Amazon
More Info
6
Amish Paste Tomato - 50 Seeds - Heirloom Amish Tomato Variety, Super for Sauce & Canning, USA-Grown, Non-GMO Heirloom Tomato Seeds for Planting Outdoors in The Home Garden, Thresh Seed Company
Thresh Seed Co.
8.4
VIEW DEAL
Buy on Amazon
✓
Amish heirloom variety discovered in Lancaster, Pennsylvania, but thought to have originated in Wisconsin around 1870. One of the most beloved heirloom tomatoes. Featured in Dr. Carolyn Male's book "100 Heirloom Tomatoes for the American Garden."
✓
Indeterminate plants produce good yields of 8-12oz oblong or slightly tapered tomatoes that have an excellent flavor and just the right amount of juice
✓
Flavorful tomatoes are great for canning because fruit are meaty, few-seeded, and coreless, but their perfectly balanced flavor also makes them great for fresh eating
✓
Easy to Grow! GMO-free, chemical-free, USA-grown seeds; Regularly tested to ensure at least 85% germination. You too can grow you very own heirloom chilli peppers with our premium, guaranteed-to-grow seed. MO-free, chemical-free seeds are U.S-grown and regularly tested to ensure at least 85% germination
✓
Durable packaging protects seeds from light and moisture, extending the survival of the seeds by years; A great choice for preparedness seed vaults; Resealable zipper tops make for convenient storage and planting
Learn more
on Amazon
More Info
7
Burpee 'Amish Paste', Tomato Seeds, 25 Non-GMO seeds
Burpee
8.2
VIEW DEAL
Buy on Amazon
✓
EASY GROW SEEDS: Healthy, indeterminate tomato vines produce all summer long, beginning about 85 days after transplanting into the outdoor garden. Bred to thrive, these seeds produce healthy 36" tall plants with an 18" spread and a 8-12oz fruit harvest.
✓
NON-GMO: Each packet contains 25 non-GMO seeds. Burpee offers the highest quality, non-GMO seeds hand-picked by expert horticulturalists for growing in the home garden. Our germination rates are 35% higher than industry standards.
✓
CLASSIC TOMATO VARIETY: Acorn-shaped Wisconsin Heirloom for paste, as a slicer, and in sauces.
✓
SEED STARTING TIP: Sow tomato seeds indoors 6-8 weeks before average last frost. Harden off young tomato plants by leaving them outdoors in their containers up to a week before transplanting, after all danger of frost.
✓
Since 1876: Generations of customers have trusted Burpee to deliver the highest quality products and service. Gardeners rely on Burpee for accurate plant information and how-to tips that make gardening easier and more successful. Let’s grow together!
✓
ANNUAL: For all growing zones from 1-13. Sunlight exposure = full-sun
Learn more
on Amazon
More Info
8
Survival Garden Seeds - Amish Paste Tomato Seed for Planting - Packet with Instructions to Plant and Grow Tomatoes in Your Home Vegetable Garden - Indeterminate Non-GMO Heirloom Variety Large Harvest
SURVIVAL GARDEN SEEDS
7.6
VIEW DEAL
Buy on Amazon
✓
Slow Food Ark of Taste Tomato - Amish paste tomatoes are a distinctive and delicious food facing extinction. Help preserve this delightful variety by planting it in your own garden.
✓
Great Canned or Fresh - This heirloom variety from Amish farm communities is prized for the 8-12 ounce plum shaped fruits with dense flesh. Eat fresh from the garden or can your own delicious sauces, pastes, and purees.
✓
Grow Now or Later - Plant now or store for future growing seasons. Will remain viable for years if stored in a cool dry location. Each packet has instructions for saving seeds so you can perpetuate your harvest and share with others.
✓
Easy to Grow - Seeds are packed in a beautiful paper packet with instructions for successful growing and germination in your own home garden. Getting started is simple for both beginner and experienced gardeners.
✓
Quality Seeds - Safe, non-hybrid non-GMO heirloom seeds proudly sourced in the USA for your family to plant and grow for years to come. Open-pollinated, naturally grown and selected to ensure the best germination rates.
Learn more
on Amazon
More Info
9
Amish Paste Tomato Seeds - Ultimate Paste Tomato for Sauces - Non GMO
Marde Ross & Company
7.4
VIEW DEAL
Buy on Amazon
✓
Considered the ultimate paste tomato, Amish Paste is a big, delicious red-flesh Roma tomato that is perfect for paste, canning, and sauce. One of the largest tomatoes of this variety, these seeds were originally sourced from the Amish in Lancaster, PA.
✓
Plant Seed 1/4" Indoors and 1/2" Outdoors when Warm
✓
Keep Moist While Germinating and Keep Moist Outside but don't Overwater
✓
Non GMO and Neonicotinoid Seed
✓
Marde Ross & Company has been a Licensed California Nursery since 1985.
Learn more
on Amazon
More Info
10
Tomato, Amish Paste ~ Heirloom-From The Amish Here In Pennsylvania ~ 100 Seeds!
SVI
7.2
VIEW DEAL
Buy on Amazon
✓
Country/Region Of Manufacture:Italy, Mpn:Vegetable/seed/annual
✓
Brand:Lycopersicon lycopersicum, Country Of Manufacture:Italy
✓
Model:Amish Paste, Italian Heirloom Variety:Freshly Harvest
Learn more
on Amazon
More Info
How we create our
“
Top 10
“ lists?
Our algorithms collect and evaluate information on millions of products and rank them based on customer reviews, popularity, price and more.
LEARN MORE
Related Reviews
Best
Heirloom Tomato Seeds
View List
Best
Tomato Seeds Heirloom
View List
Best
Heirloom Seeds Tomato
View List
Popular Lists
Headphones
Tablets
Women's Jewelry
Dog Food
Bath Towels
Men's Boxer
Guitars
Robotic Vacuums
Pool Inflatable
TV Streamers
Best Reviews Guide Newsletter
Get exclusive articles, recommendations, shopping tips and sales alerts
SUBSCRIBE